The 130,000-sq.-ft. Elm Street School in Gardner, Mass.—built in 1923—had failing oil-fired boilers, and a stack that defied physical principles and noise complaints. “One of the owner complaints was wet steam and banging. The previous system had a reputation for noise at certain points in the operation, notably start-up,” says Bradford White, senior mechanical engineer Read more
MacRitchie Engineering
The 130,000-sq.-ft. Elm Street School in Gardner, Mass.—built in 1923—had failing oil-fired boilers, and a stack that defied physical principles and noise complaints. “One of the owner complaints was wet steam and banging. The previous system had a reputation for noise at certain points in the operation, notably start-up,” says Bradford White, senior mechanical engineer, MacRitchie Engineering, Inc.
What the stack will serve. Three Weil-McLain low pressure steam boilers. I insisted on dropped headers, full equalizers and extended boiler risers. In addition, the 8 inch risers to the building header also is effectively a drop header configuration. System will run on 2.2 psig. Full modulating fire.
MacRitchie Engineering, Inc., a small but nimble consulting engineering firm providing HVAC, plumbing, fire protection and electrical design services, was called for boiler replacement, oil conversion to add gas for dual fuel firing, new stack, boiler room valves, boiler feed unit, fuel oil pumps and controls, plus associated electrical and plumbing/gas work.
Stack arrives ready for off-loading. A 60 foot stack in two pieces, all 304 and 316 stainless to be assembled and rigged in one piece. White designed the stack for optimal draft with two or three boilers firing. The height will typically mean too much draft so we have a draft control system, dampers on each boiler.
According to White, “We sized the boilers based on a triangluated combination of connected radiation plus analysis of fuel bills and weather data as a cross-check.
“We went with extra-tall risers (60 inches off the boiler waterline), a dropped header and header outfeed to the building header also dropping into the top as is good practice,” says White.
New LPR return header and pad for the boiler feed unit. 374 gallons, quadplex pumps with manual standby.
Boiler room trap replacement, new insulation, boiler feed unit, condensate pumps and fuel pumps were installed to replace the existing. An engineered combustion air system was installed. Each boiler will have a 1″ F&T trap for waterline control and each boiler will have a dedicated feed water pump. The fourth pump will be a manual valve-over/switch-over should any one fail. This fourth pump valve arrangement can be directed to any of the boilers in parallel.
Offloading the base section. Note mounting flange and cleanout door.
Once they get the horizontal breeching and draft control dampers installed, they will be installing that small-bore piping (blow-down, boiler feed and overflow control) which will cross the volume and floor space behind the boilers. The floor is clear for staging now.
A new stack, 60 feet tall, double wall insulated with one-inch air space, and of stainless steel construction was recently rigged into place.
Inner wall SS clamp system.
With the project starting in July 2015 and wrapping up this month, as for energy savings, it is too early to project. “The main maintenance supervisor is a former mechanical contractor who knows steam. Nothing predicted specifically, but with fully modulating boilers and low-range pressure controls plus current code insulation thicknesses and new traps at least in the boiler room, they will do as well as they possibly could,” says White.
Stack assembled and rigging begins.
Aligned to be inserted into an existing 60 inch masonry chimney. Base is three stories below. Base flange was bolted to a reinforced pad.
Inside the Jobsite
Boiler — Three (3) Weil-McLain 1288 low pressure steam boilers. Two carry the building, one is standby.
Pumps — Shippensburg (Shipco) quad-plex boiler feed unit with epoxy lined tank. Each boiler will have its own pump plus a common manually valved standby pump.
Piping — All steam and condensate is A106 carbon steel with welded fittings for sizes 2.5 inches and larger. Smaller pipe is the same but malleable iron fittings. Pumped condensate and blowdown piping is A53 Grade B carbon steel.
Stack and Breeching — Schebler Chimney Systems, Bettendorf, IA. Included 2-piece chimney stack, breeching system and pressure-responsive draft control system for each boiler.
Date started:
July, 2015
Date Finished:
October, 2015
Workers onsite: Varied, ranging from two to six pipefitters, electricians and plumbers.
Budget: $960,000 for the steam plant work and stack.